TEI:Body: Difference between revisions

From TEI-XML in Egyptology and Coptic Studies

Jump to: navigation, search
Werningd (talk | contribs)
m Status hint added
Werningd (talk | contribs)
TEI tagging of text elements: Review destructions
 
(33 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Citation:'''
Werning, Daniel A. and wiki contributors. "TEI:Body" <nowiki>https://wikis.hu-berlin.de/teiegyptology/TEI:Body</nowiki>, in: ''TEI-XML in Eyptology and Coptic Studies'' <nowiki>https://wikis.hu-berlin.de/teiegyptology/</nowiki>, ed. by Daniel A. Werning, Berlin: Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin (accessed on: ______).
== TEI tagging of text elements ==
== TEI tagging of text elements ==
{{InDiscussion}}
 
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="border:solid"
{| class="wikitable" style="border:solid"
|-
!  '''Phenomenon''' !! Traditional philological markup !! '''Suggested philological markup''' !! '''TEI/EpiDoc markup '''(cf. [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/app-alltrans.html EpiDoc Guidelines]) !! '''Reference'''
|-
| colspan="5" |==== '''LINE BREAKS, LAYOUT''' ====
|-
|  '''Page/side beginning or break''', (with indication scan file name) || (Recto:) || (Recto:) || '''&lt;pb n="'''R'''" /&gt; <br/> &lt;pb n="'''R'''" facs="'''P_12345_R.tif'''" /&gt; <br/> &lt;pb n="'''V'''" facs="'''P_12345_V.tif'''" /&gt;'''<br/> '''&lt;pb n="'''outside'''" facs="'''P_12346_R.tif'''" /&gt;<br/> &lt;pb n="'''inside'''" facs="'''P_12346_V.tif'''" /&gt;''' || [http://www.tei-c.org/release/doc/tei-p5-doc/de/html/ref-pb.html TEI]
|-
|  '''Line break''' (if basic "line" is horizontal) or '''column''' '''break '''(if basic "line" is vertical, i.e., column) between words  || ꞽmn.t (2) pw || ꞽmn.t <nowiki>|</nowiki><sup>2</sup> pw || ꞽmn.t '''&lt;lb n="'''2'''" /&gt;'''pw || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-linebreak.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Line/column '''break inside a word''' || ꞽmn.t (2) || ꞽ<nowiki>|</nowiki><sup>2</sup>mn.t || ꞽ'''&lt;lb n="'''2'''" break="no" /&gt;'''mn.t  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-linebreakinword.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''First line/column''', with indication of writing direction  || (1) ←<br />(x+1) ←
| <nowiki>|</nowiki><sup>1(←)</sup><br /><nowiki>|</nowiki><sup>x+1(←)</sup>
| '''&lt;lb n="'''1'''" rend="'''horizontal-rtl'''" /&gt;'''<br/> '''&lt;lb n="'''1'''" rend="''' horizontal-ltr'''" /&gt;<br/> &lt;lb n="'''1'''" rend="'''vertical-rtl'''" /&gt;'''<br/> '''&lt;lb n="'''1'''" rend="'''vertical-ltr'''" /&gt;''' || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-linebreakdirection.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''Break''' between sections of lines/columns ("paragraphs") || (''no standard'') || ꞽmn.t (II) pw || ꞽmn.t '''&lt;cb n="'''II'''" /&gt;'''pw || 
|-
|  '''Rubrum''' || <u>ꞽmn.t pw</u> || <u>ꞽmn.t pw</u>  || '''&lt;hi rend="'''rubrum'''"&gt;'''ꞽmn'''&lt;/hi&gt;'''.t pw  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-charactershighlighted.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''Highlighted characters''' (e.g. tall [e.g., in Demotic], ...) || (''unmarked'') || <u>ḥsb.t 10</u> || '''&lt;hi rend="'''tall'''"&gt;'''ḥsb.t'''&lt;/hi&gt;''' 10  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-charactershighlighted.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  (Remarkable) '''free space''' on the text support in a line (''vacat'')  || (''no standard'') || sꜢ (''vac.'') ꞽrm Ꜣrsn || sꜢ '''&lt;space quantity="'''3'''" unit="'''quadrates'''" /&gt;''' ꞽrm Ꜣrsn  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-vacatchar.html EpiDoc]
|-
| colspan="5" |==== '''ORIGINAL/ANCIENT EDITORIAL CORRECTIONS''' ====
|-
|-
! Phenomenon !! Traditional !! Options of TEI/EpiDoc encoding || References and comments
|Ancient addition '''to the line'''
|(''no standard'')
|sḏm`=k´ sw
|sḏm '''&lt;add place="beside"&gt;'''=k'''&lt;/add&gt;''' sw
|
|-
|  Ancient addition '''above the line'''|| || ⲁⲛⲟⲕ\ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ/ϯ || ⲁⲛⲟⲕ'''&lt;add place="above"&gt;'''ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ'''&lt;/add&gt;'''ϯⲙⲁⲣⲧⲏⲣⲟⲥ || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-addition.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Ancient addition '''below the line'''|| || ⲁⲛⲟⲕ/ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ\ϯ || ⲁⲛⲟⲕ'''&lt;add place="below"&gt;'''ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ'''&lt;/add&gt;'''ϯⲙⲁⲣⲧⲏⲣⲟⲥ || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-addition.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''Characters deleted''' in antiquity (''rasura''), completely lost  || (''no standard'') || ⟦-3Q-⟧ nb-nṯr.(w) || '''&lt;del rend="erasure"&gt;&lt;gap reason="lost" quantity="'''3'''" unit="'''quadrates'''" /&gt;&lt;/del&gt;''' nb-nṯr.(w) || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-erasedlost.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Characters deleted in antiquity, completely lost, modern reconstruction || (''no standard'') || ⟦[ꞽmn-rꜤ]⟧ nb-nṯr.(w) || '''&lt;del rend="erasure"&gt;&lt;supplied reason="lost" cert="'''high'''"&gt;'''ꞽmn-rꜤ'''&lt;/supplied&gt;&lt;/del&gt;''' nb-nṯr.(w) || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-erasedillegible.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Characters deleted in antiquity, reading uncertain  || (''no standard'') || ⟦⸮ꞽmn-rꜤ?⟧ nb-nṯr.(w) || '''&lt;del rend="erasure"&gt;&lt;unclear reason="damaged"&gt;'''ꞽmn-rꜤ'''&lt;/unclear&gt;&lt;/del&gt;''' nb-nṯr.(w) || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-erased.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Characters deleted in antiquity, still legible  || (''no standard'') || ⟦ꞽmn-rꜤ⟧ nb-nṯr.(w) || '''&lt;del rend="erasure"&gt;'''ꞽmn-rꜤ'''&lt;/del&gt;''' nb-nṯr.(w) || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-erased.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Characters crossed out in antiquity, still legible  ||  (''no standard'')||  sḏm<nowiki>{{</nowiki>=f<nowiki>}}</nowiki>=k|| sḏm'''&lt;del rend="'''slashes'''"&gt;'''=f'''&lt;/del&gt;'''=k ||
|-
|-
| Word || ''jmn.t'' || <nowiki><w>jmn.t</w></nowiki> ||  <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013_example" />
|'''Characters written over deleted characters''' (''rasura'')
|(''no standard'')
|⟪ꞽmn-rꜤ⟫ nb-nṯr.(w)
|'''<add place="overstrike">'''ꞽmn-rꜤ'''</add>'''
|[https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-struckovererasure.html EpiDoc]
|-
| colspan="5" |==== '''TEXTUAL DESTRUCTION''' ====
|-
| Gap, '''completely destroyed'''|| sꜢ […] Ꜣrsn || sꜢ <nowiki>[…]</nowiki> Ꜣrsn || sꜢ '''&lt;gap reason="lost" extent="undefined" /&gt;''' Ꜣrsn  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/ref-gap.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Gap of unknown length, completely destroyed|| (''no standard'') || sꜢ <nowiki>[…]</nowiki> Ꜣrsn || sꜢ '''&lt;gap reason="lost" extent="unknown" unit="quadrates"/&gt;''' Ꜣrsn  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-lostcharunknown.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Gap of unknown length at the end of a text, completely destroyed || ꞽmn.t  […]|| ꞽmn.t <nowiki>[…]</nowiki>|| ꞽmn.t '''&lt;gap reason="lost" extent="unknown" /&gt;'''||
|-
|  Gap of '''certain or approximate length''', completely destroyed || (''no standard'') || sꜢ <nowiki>[…3Q…]</nowiki> ꞽrm<br/>sꜢ <nowiki>[…ca.3Q…]</nowiki> ꞽrm<br/>sꜢ <nowiki>[…ca.5–7Q…]</nowiki> ꞽrm || sꜢ '''&lt;gap reason="lost" quantity="'''3'''" unit="'''quadrates'''" /&gt;''' ı͗rm <br /> sꜢ '''&lt;gap reason="lost" quantity="'''3'''" unit="'''quadrates'''" precision="'''low'''" /&gt;''' ꞽrm<br /> sꜢ '''&lt;gap reason="lost" atleast="'''5'''" atmost="'''7'''" unit="'''quadrates'''" /&gt;''' ꞽrm  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-lostcharknown.html EpiDoc] <br /> [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-illegiblecharapprox.html EpiDoc] <br /> [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-lostcharpraenomen.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Gap of unknown length, '''barely legible'''|| (''no standard'') || sꜢ ⸢…⸣ Ꜣrsn || sꜢ '''&lt;gap reason="illegible" extent="unknown" unit="quadrates"/&gt;''' Ꜣrsn  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-lostcharunknown.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Gap of certain or approximate length, barely legible || (''no standard'') || sꜢ ⸢…3Q…⸣ ꞽrm Ꜣrsn<br/>sꜢ ⸢…ca.3Q…⸣ ꞽrm Ꜣrsn<br/>sꜢ ⸢…ca.5–7Q…⸣ ꞽrm Ꜣrsn || sꜢ '''&lt;gap reason="illegible" quantity="'''3'''" unit="'''quadrates'''" /&gt;''' ı͗rm Ꜣrsn<br /> sꜢ '''&lt;gap reason="illegible" quantity="'''3'''" unit="'''quadrates'''" precision="'''low'''" /&gt;''' ꞽrm Ꜣrsn<br /> sꜢ '''&lt;gap reason="illegible" atleast="'''5'''" atmost="'''7'''" unit="'''quadrates'''" /&gt;''' ꞽrm  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-lostcharknown.html EpiDoc] <br /> [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-illegiblecharapprox.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''Modern reconstruction''' in gap (based on editors intuition) || ꞽ[mn].t || ꞽ[mn].t || ꞽ'''&lt;supplied reason="lost"&gt;'''mn'''&lt;/supplied&gt;'''.t ꞽ'''&lt;supplied reason="lost" cert="'''high'''"&gt;'''mn'''&lt;/supplied&gt;'''.t<br /> ꞽ'''&lt;supplied reason="lost" cert="'''low'''"&gt;'''mn'''&lt;/supplied&gt;'''.t || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-restored.html EpiDoc] <br /> [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-restoreduncert.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Modern reconstruction in gap '''based on parallel text witnesses'''|| sꜢ [Ptwlmys] ꞽrm || sꜢ [Ptwlmys] ꞽrm || sꜢ '''&lt;supplied reason="lost" evidence="parallel"&gt;'''Ptwlmys'''&lt;/supplied&gt;''' ı͗rm  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-parallelcopy.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Characters now lost, but '''recorded by earlier scholars'''|| (''no standard'') || ꞽ[“mn”].t || ꞽ'''&lt;supplied reason="lost" evidence="previous_editor"&gt;'''mn'''&lt;/supplied&gt;'''.t  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-previouseditor.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''Partial destruction''', but perfectly or unambiguously legible  || ꞽmn.t<br />ꞽmn⸢.t⸣
| ꞽmn⸢.t⸣ || ꞽmn'''&lt;damage&gt;'''.t'''&lt;/damage&gt;'''<br /> ꞽmn'''&lt;damage degree="'''medium'''"&gt;'''.t'''&lt;/damage&gt;'''<br /> ꞽmn'''&lt;damage degree="'''low'''"&gt;'''.t'''&lt;/damage&gt;'''|| [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-damaged.html EpiDoc]
|-
Partial destruction, interpretation '''somewhat ambiguous'''|| ꞽmn.t?<br />ꞽmn⸢.t?⸣<br />δεδαία̣ται
| ꞽmn⸢⸮.t?⸣<br />δεδαία̣ται  || ꞽmn'''&lt;unclear reason="damaged"&gt;'''.t'''&lt;/unclear&gt;''' <br /> δεδαί'''&lt;unclear reason="damaged"&gt;'''α'''&lt;/unclear&gt;'''ται || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-ambiguous.html EpiDoc]
|-
| colspan="5" |==== '''MODERN EDITORIAL CORRECTIONS, EMENDATIONS, IDEALIZATIONS, ...''' ====
|-
|-
| Sentence || ''jmn.t pw'' || <nowiki><s>jmn.t pw</s></nowiki> ||  <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013_example" />
|'''Questionable interpretation''' of hieroglyphs
|wꜥb.t?
|⸮wꜥb.t?
|'''&lt;unclear&gt;'''wꜥb.t'''&lt;/unclear&gt;'''
|[https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-ambiguous.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''Erroneous''' '''ancient addition '''|| ꞽmn{.t}-rꜤ || ꞽmn{.t}-rꜤ || ꞽmn'''&lt;surplus reason="mistake"&gt;'''t'''&lt;/surplus&gt;'''-rꜤ<br /> ꞽmn'''&lt;surplus reason="mistake" cert="'''high'''"&gt;'''t'''&lt;/surplus&gt;'''-rꜤ <br /> ꞽmn'''&lt;surplus reason="mistake" cert="'''low'''"&gt;'''t'''&lt;/surplus&gt;'''-rꜤ || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-superfluous.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''Erroneous''' ancient''' repetition'''|| ꞽ{ꞽ}mn.t<br />{ꞽmn} ꞽmn.t || ꞽ{ꞽ}mn.t<br />{ꞽmn} ꞽmn.t || ꞽ'''&lt;surplus reason="repeated"&gt;'''ꞽ'''&lt;/surplus&gt;'''mn.t <br /> ꞽ'''&lt;surplus reason="repeated" cert="'''high'''"&gt;'''ꞽ'''&lt;/surplus&gt;'''mn.t <br /> ꞽ'''&lt;surplus reason="repeated" cert="'''low'''"&gt;'''ꞽ'''&lt;/surplus&gt;'''mn.t || [http://www.tei-c.org/release/doc/tei-p5-doc/en/html/ref-surplus.html TEI]
|-
Traditional 'superfluous' double spelling of phonemes (sound change) || zw{r}ꞽ<br />zwrꞽ <br />t{r}ꞽ <br />trꞽ
| zw{r}ꞽ <br/> t{r}ꞽ || zw'''&lt;surplus reason="traditional_orthography"&gt;'''r'''&lt;/surplus&gt;'''ꞽ  ||
|-
|  '''Erroneous''' ancient''' omission '''|| ꞽmn⟨.w⟩ || ꞽmn⟨.w⟩ || ꞽmn'''&lt;supplied reason="omitted"&gt;'''.w'''&lt;/supplied&gt;''' <br /> ꞽmn'''&lt;supplied reason="omitted" cert="'''middle'''"&gt;'''.w'''&lt;/supplied&gt;'''|| [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-omitted.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''Erroneous''' ancient '''substitution'''|| ꞽmn.{t}⟨w⟩<br />ꞽmn.⟨w⟩
| ꞽmn.{t}⟨w⟩ || ꞽmn.'''&lt;choice&gt;&lt;sic&gt;'''t'''&lt;/sic&gt;&lt;corr&gt;'''w'''&lt;/corr&gt;&lt;/choice&gt;'''|| [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-erroneoussubstitution.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''Regularization''' of transcription, according to Old Egyptian spelling  || w{d}⟨ḏ⟩=f<br />wḏ=f<br />wd=f<br />={t}⟨ṯ⟩n<br />=ṯn<br />=tn || w{d}⟨ḏ⟩=f<br />={t}⟨ṯ⟩n || w'''&lt;choice&gt;&lt;orig&gt;'''d'''&lt;/orig&gt;&lt;reg type="Old_Egyptian_form"&gt;'''ḏ'''&lt;/reg&gt;&lt;/choice&gt;'''=f<br /> ='''&lt;choice&gt;&lt;orig&gt;'''t'''&lt;/orig&gt;&lt;reg type="Old_Egyptian_form &gt;'''ṯ'''&lt;/reg&gt;&lt;/choice&gt;'''n || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-regularization.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''Regularization''' of transcription, towards ''plene'' spelling  || sḏm.t(w)=f || sḏm.t(w)=f || sḏm.t'''&lt;choice&gt;&lt;orig/&gt;&lt;reg type="plene_spelling"&gt;'''w'''&lt;/reg&gt;&lt;/choice&gt;'''=f || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-regularization.html EpiDoc]
|-
| rowspan="2" |  '''Regularization''' of transcription, reconstruction according to grammatical theory  || pr(ꞽ)=f<br />prꞽ=f<br />pri̯=f || pr(ꞽ)=f || pr'''&lt;choice&gt;&lt;orig/&gt;&lt;reg type="theoretical"&gt;'''''ꞽ'''''&lt;/reg&gt;&lt;/choice&gt;'''f || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-regularization.html EpiDoc]
|-
|-
| Line break (manuscript) || <nowiki>|</nowiki><sup>x+1</sup> || <lb n="x+1" /> || <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013_example" />
| ꞽw=f (ḥr) sdm || ꞽw=f (ḥr) sdm || ꞽw=f '''&lt;choice&gt;&lt;orig/&gt;&lt;reg type="paradigmatic_normalization"&gt;'''ḥr'''&lt;/reg&gt;&lt;/choice&gt;''' sdm ||
|-
|-
| Erroneous addition || ''<nowiki>jmn{.t}</nowiki>'' || <nowiki>jmn<surplus reason="mistake">t</surplus></nowiki> || <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013">Cf. Werning, Daniel A. 2013 (March). ''Datenkodierung in TEI XML im Rubensohn-Projekt'' http://wwwuser.gwdg.de/~dwernin/drafts/Werning-TEI_im_Rubensohn_Projekt.pdf, pp. 3-4.</ref>
|Second/third/... reading of characters only written once (''licensed/systemic '''haplography''''')
|(''no standard'')
|ꜥnḫ nb wꜣs ⸨nb⸩ snb ⸨nb⸩
|'''<supplied''' '''reason="haplography">'''nb'''<supplied>'''
|
|-
| colspan="5" |==== '''FOOTNOTES, COMMENTS, VARIA''' ====
|-
|  Modern '''footnote''' / endnote [can be automatized; no need to encode by hand] || ꞽmn.t tw<sup>1<br /> ________________<br /> 1 </sup>Congruent. || ꞽmn.t tw<sup>1<br /> ________________<br /> 1 </sup>Congruent. || ꞽmn.t tw'''&lt;note&gt;'''Congruent.'''&lt;/note&gt; '''|| [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-editorsnote.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  '''Change of hand'''|| (''not marked'') || ꞽmn.t (''change of hand'') pw || ꞽmn.t '''&lt;handShift cert="'''high'''" /&gt;'''pw || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-handshift.html EpiDoc]
|-
|  Text '''not completed'''|| (''no standard'') || ꞽmn.t (''unfinished'') || ꞽmn.t '''&lt;gap reason="omitted" extent="unknown" /&gt;''' Ꜣrsn  || [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-textnotcompleted.html EpiDoc]
|-
| rowspan="2" |  '''Abbreviation''', without/with expansion  || rowspan="2" | ⲓ⳯ⲥ
s(nb)
| rowspan="2" | ⲓ⳯ⲥ
s(nb)
| '''&lt;abbr&gt;'''ⲓ'''&lt;am&gt;'''⳯'''&lt;/am&gt;'''ⲥ'''&lt;/abbr&gt;'''|| [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-abbrevnotex.html EpiDoc] <br /> [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-abbrevmark.html EpiDoc] <br /> [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-abbrevfully.html EpiDoc]
|-
|-
| Traditional, ‘superfluous’ spelling<ref>Wolfgang Schenkel. <sup>5</sup>2012. ''Tübinger Einführung in die klassisch-ägyptische Sprache und Schrift'', 5th, [green] ed., Tübingen: [Wolfgang Schenkel], Ch. 2.5.</ref> || ''<nowiki>zw{r}j</nowiki>'' || <nowiki>zw<surplus reason="traditional_orthography">r</surplus>j</nowiki> || <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013" />
| '''&lt;expan&gt;&lt;abbr&gt;'''ⲓ'''&lt;am&gt;'''⳯'''&lt;/am&gt;&lt;/abbr&gt;&lt;ex&gt;'''ⲥⲟⲩ'''&lt;/ex&gt;&lt;abbr&gt;''''''&lt;/abbr&gt;&lt;/expan&gt;<br /> &lt;expan&gt;''' '''&lt;abbr&gt;'''s'''&lt;/abbr&gt;''' '''&lt;ex&gt;'''nb'''&lt;/ex&gt;&lt;/expan&gt;''' ||
|-
|-  
| Erroneous omission || ''<nowiki>jmn<.w></nowiki>'' || <nowiki>jmn<supplied reason="omission">.w</supplied></nowiki> ||  
| '''Sign or symbol''' not present in Unicode || (''no standard'')
|-
| <nowiki>*</nowiki>''cross''*
| Idealized reconstructed morphology || ''<nowiki>sḏm.t(w)=f</nowiki>'' || <nowiki>sḏm.t<supplied reason="idealization">w</supplied>=f</nowiki> || <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013" />
| '''&lt;g type="'''cross'''" /&gt;'''<br /> '''&lt;g type="'''circle'''" /&gt;'''|| [https://epidoc.stoa.org/gl/latest/trans-symbol.html EpiDoc]
|-
|-  
| Erroneous substitution || ''<nowiki>jmn.{t}<w></nowiki>'' || <nowiki>jmn.<choice><sic>t</sic><corr>w</corr></choice></nowiki> || <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013" />
| colspan="5" |==== '''WORD AND SENTENCE BOUNDARIES''' (optional) ====  
|-
|-  
| Gap (of certain length) || ''<nowiki>sꜢ [///] ı͗rm Ꜣrsn</nowiki>'' || <nowiki>sꜢ <gap reason="destruction" quantity="4" unit="quadrats" /> ı͗rm Ꜣrsn</nowiki> || <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013" />
| Sentence boundaries || ꞽmn.t pw || ꞽmn.t pw || '''&lt;s&gt;'''ꞽmn.t pw'''&lt;/s&gt;'''  ||
|-
|-  
| Gap (of unknown length) || ''<nowiki>sꜢ [///...///] Ꜣrsn</nowiki>'' || <nowiki>sꜢ <gap reason="destruction" extent="unknown"/> Ꜣrsn</nowiki> || <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013_example" />
| Word boundaries texts without spaces between words || ⲁⲛⲟⲕⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥϯ || ⲁⲛⲟⲕⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥϯ || '''&lt;w&gt;'''ⲁⲛⲟⲕ'''&lt;/w&gt;&lt;w&gt;'''ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ'''&lt;/w&gt;&lt;w&gt;'''ϯ'''&lt;/w&gt;''' ||
|-
| Partial destruction || ''jmn⌈.t⌉'' || jmn<unclear>.t</unclear> || <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013_example">Werning, Daniel A. 2013 (March). Example of a TEI file from the Rubensohn Project http://wwwuser.gwdg.de/~dwernin/drafts/Werning-Rubensohn_Projekt-Beispieldatensatz-TEI.pdf</ref>
|-
| Addition above the line (Leiden System) || <nowiki>ⲁⲛⲟⲕ `ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ´ ϯ ⲙⲁⲣⲧⲏⲣⲟⲥ</nowiki> || <nowiki>ⲁⲛⲟⲕ <add place="supralinear">ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ</add> ϯ ⲙⲁⲣⲧⲏⲣⲟⲥ</nowiki> || <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013" />
|}
|}


Line 33: Line 147:


=== Semantic annotation supported by TEI ===
=== Semantic annotation supported by TEI ===
{{InDiscussion}}
====Personal names and individual persons====
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="border:solid"
Example for individual person in line with EpiDoc 8.21 Guidelines:<ref>Cf. the EpiDoc suggestions on http://www.stoa.org/epidoc/gl/latest/idx-persnames.html.</ref>
|-
  <persName
! Information !! Traditional !! Options of TEI/EpiDoc encoding || References and comments
    type="royal"  
|-
    ref="http://www.trismegistos.org/person/12909"
| rowspan=2 | Personal names || ''pr-ꜤꜢ  Ptrwmys'' || <nowiki>pr-ꜤꜢ <persName type="royal" key="Ptolemaios III.">Ptrwmys</persName></nowiki> || <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013_example" />
    key="Ptolemaios_III_Euergetes_I">
|-
    <name
| ''zẖꜢ Jmn-ḥtp'' || <nowiki>zẖꜢ <persName type="non_royal" key="Amenhotep">Jmn-ḥtp</persName></nowiki> || <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013_example" />
      nymref="http://www.trismegistos.org/name/5317"
|-
      key="Ptolemaios">
| Place names || ''n tꜢ sḫ.t Yb'' || <nowiki>n tꜢ sḫ.t<placeName type="settlement" key="Elephantine">Yb</placeName></nowiki> ||  <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013_example" />
      Ptrwmys
|-
    </name>
| Dates || ''n ḥsb.t 11'' || <nowiki>n <date when-custom="11" datingPoint="PtolemaiosIII." datingMethod="regnal year" when="-236">ḥsb.t 11</date></nowiki> ||  <ref name="Werning_XML_Rubensohn_2013_example" />
  </persName>
|}
 
Examples for name (without identification with individual person):
  <persName  
    type="non_royal"  
    key="Amenophis">
    <name
      nymref="http://www.trismegistos.org/name/8042"
      key="Amenophis">  
      ꞽmn-m-ꞽp.t
    </name>
  </persName>
 
====Place names====
Example:
  <placeName type="settlement" key="Elephantine"
      ref="http://www.trismegistos.org/place/621">Yb</placeName>
 
Alternatives for '''"'''settlement'''"''' are '''"'''district'''"''', '''"'''region'''"''', '''"'''country'''".'''
 
====Dates====
For dating by regnal years, use '''@when-custom''' and '''@datingMethod''', and seperate ruler and regnal year by ":":<ref>Cf. the example in http://www.tei-c.org/release/doc/tei-p5-doc/de/html/ref-att.datable.custom.html.</ref>
  <date when-custom="Ptolemaios_III:11" datingMethod="#regnal_year">ḥsb.t 11</date>
 
Example for Coptic month:
  <date when-custom="Parmuti:9">ⲡⲁⲣⲙⲁⲧ ⲑ</date>
 
If you can provide a modern calendar year (TLA chronology, like in the database), add '''notBefore="'''...'''" notAfter="'''...'''"''' plus a '''precision="'''...'''" '''attribute, e.g.  
  <date when-custom="Ptolemaios_III:11" datingMethod="#regnal_year"
      notBefore="-0236" notAfter="-0235" precision="high">ḥsb.t 11</date>
  <date when-custom="Parmuti:9" notBefore="0450" notAfter="0465"
      precision="medium">ⲡⲁⲣⲙⲁⲧ ⲑ</date>
 
Instead of a time span one may refer to an individual year using a '''when="'''...'''" '''attribute:
  <date when-custom="Ptolemaios_III:11" datingMethod="#regnal_year"  
      when="-0236" precision="high">ḥsb.t 11</date>
 
Years BC are negative values; year values must have 4 digits. Months may follow and must have 2 digits:
  notBefore="-0236-05" notAfter="-0235-04"  
or
  when="0455-03"


=== Morphosyntactic annotation ===
=== Morphosyntactic annotation ===
{{InDiscussion}}
{{InDiscussion}}
<!-- fs and f emelents / stand-off or inline? / Handout S. Schweitzer -->
<!-- fs and f elements / stand-off or inline? / Handout S. Schweitzer -->


== References ==
== References ==

Latest revision as of 10:36, 30 March 2026

Citation:

Werning, Daniel A. and wiki contributors. "TEI:Body" https://wikis.hu-berlin.de/teiegyptology/TEI:Body, in: TEI-XML in Eyptology and Coptic Studies https://wikis.hu-berlin.de/teiegyptology/, ed. by Daniel A. Werning, Berlin: Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin (accessed on: ______).

TEI tagging of text elements

Phenomenon Traditional philological markup Suggested philological markup TEI/EpiDoc markup (cf. EpiDoc Guidelines) Reference
==== LINE BREAKS, LAYOUT ====
Page/side beginning or break, (with indication scan file name) (Recto:) (Recto:) <pb n="R" />
<pb n="
R" facs="P_12345_R.tif" />
<pb n="
V" facs="P_12345_V.tif" />
<pb n="outside" facs="P_12346_R.tif" />
<pb n="
inside" facs="P_12346_V.tif" />
TEI
Line break (if basic "line" is horizontal) or column break (if basic "line" is vertical, i.e., column) between words ꞽmn.t (2) pw ꞽmn.t |2 pw ꞽmn.t <lb n="2" />pw EpiDoc
Line/column break inside a word ꞽmn.t (2) ꞽ|2mn.t <lb n="2" break="no" />mn.t EpiDoc
First line/column, with indication of writing direction (1) ←
(x+1) ←
|1(←)
|x+1(←)
<lb n="1" rend="horizontal-rtl" />
<lb n="1" rend=" horizontal-ltr" />
<lb n="
1" rend="vertical-rtl" />
<lb n="1" rend="vertical-ltr" />
EpiDoc
Break between sections of lines/columns ("paragraphs") (no standard) ꞽmn.t (II) pw ꞽmn.t <cb n="II" />pw
Rubrum ꞽmn.t pw ꞽmn.t pw <hi rend="rubrum">ꞽmn</hi>.t pw EpiDoc
Highlighted characters (e.g. tall [e.g., in Demotic], ...) (unmarked) ḥsb.t 10 <hi rend="tall">ḥsb.t</hi> 10 EpiDoc
(Remarkable) free space on the text support in a line (vacat) (no standard) sꜢ (vac.) ꞽrm Ꜣrsn sꜢ <space quantity="3" unit="quadrates" /> ꞽrm Ꜣrsn EpiDoc
==== ORIGINAL/ANCIENT EDITORIAL CORRECTIONS ====
Ancient addition to the line (no standard) sḏm`=k´ sw sḏm <add place="beside">=k</add> sw
Ancient addition above the line ⲁⲛⲟⲕ\ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ/ϯ ⲁⲛⲟⲕ<add place="above">ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ</add>ϯⲙⲁⲣⲧⲏⲣⲟⲥ EpiDoc
Ancient addition below the line ⲁⲛⲟⲕ/ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ\ϯ ⲁⲛⲟⲕ<add place="below">ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ</add>ϯⲙⲁⲣⲧⲏⲣⲟⲥ EpiDoc
Characters deleted in antiquity (rasura), completely lost (no standard) ⟦-3Q-⟧ nb-nṯr.(w) <del rend="erasure"><gap reason="lost" quantity="3" unit="quadrates" /></del> nb-nṯr.(w) EpiDoc
Characters deleted in antiquity, completely lost, modern reconstruction (no standard) ⟦[ꞽmn-rꜤ]⟧ nb-nṯr.(w) <del rend="erasure"><supplied reason="lost" cert="high">ꞽmn-rꜤ</supplied></del> nb-nṯr.(w) EpiDoc
Characters deleted in antiquity, reading uncertain (no standard) ⟦⸮ꞽmn-rꜤ?⟧ nb-nṯr.(w) <del rend="erasure"><unclear reason="damaged">ꞽmn-rꜤ</unclear></del> nb-nṯr.(w) EpiDoc
Characters deleted in antiquity, still legible (no standard) ⟦ꞽmn-rꜤ⟧ nb-nṯr.(w) <del rend="erasure">ꞽmn-rꜤ</del> nb-nṯr.(w) EpiDoc
Characters crossed out in antiquity, still legible (no standard) sḏm{{=f}}=k sḏm<del rend="slashes">=f</del>=k
Characters written over deleted characters (rasura) (no standard) ⟪ꞽmn-rꜤ⟫ nb-nṯr.(w) <add place="overstrike">ꞽmn-rꜤ</add> EpiDoc
==== TEXTUAL DESTRUCTION ====
Gap, completely destroyed sꜢ […] Ꜣrsn sꜢ […] Ꜣrsn sꜢ <gap reason="lost" extent="undefined" /> Ꜣrsn EpiDoc
Gap of unknown length, completely destroyed (no standard) sꜢ […] Ꜣrsn sꜢ <gap reason="lost" extent="unknown" unit="quadrates"/> Ꜣrsn EpiDoc
Gap of unknown length at the end of a text, completely destroyed ꞽmn.t […] ꞽmn.t […] ꞽmn.t <gap reason="lost" extent="unknown" />
Gap of certain or approximate length, completely destroyed (no standard) sꜢ […3Q…] ꞽrm
sꜢ […ca.3Q…] ꞽrm
sꜢ […ca.5–7Q…] ꞽrm
sꜢ <gap reason="lost" quantity="3" unit="quadrates" /> ı͗rm
sꜢ <gap reason="lost" quantity="3" unit="quadrates" precision="low" /> ꞽrm
sꜢ <gap reason="lost" atleast="5" atmost="7" unit="quadrates" /> ꞽrm
EpiDoc
EpiDoc
EpiDoc
Gap of unknown length, barely legible (no standard) sꜢ ⸢…⸣ Ꜣrsn sꜢ <gap reason="illegible" extent="unknown" unit="quadrates"/> Ꜣrsn EpiDoc
Gap of certain or approximate length, barely legible (no standard) sꜢ ⸢…3Q…⸣ ꞽrm Ꜣrsn
sꜢ ⸢…ca.3Q…⸣ ꞽrm Ꜣrsn
sꜢ ⸢…ca.5–7Q…⸣ ꞽrm Ꜣrsn
sꜢ <gap reason="illegible" quantity="3" unit="quadrates" /> ı͗rm Ꜣrsn
sꜢ <gap reason="illegible" quantity="3" unit="quadrates" precision="low" /> ꞽrm Ꜣrsn
sꜢ <gap reason="illegible" atleast="5" atmost="7" unit="quadrates" /> ꞽrm
EpiDoc
EpiDoc
Modern reconstruction in gap (based on editors intuition) ꞽ[mn].t ꞽ[mn].t <supplied reason="lost">mn</supplied>.t ꞽ<supplied reason="lost" cert="high">mn</supplied>.t
<supplied reason="lost" cert="low">mn</supplied>.t
EpiDoc
EpiDoc
Modern reconstruction in gap based on parallel text witnesses sꜢ [Ptwlmys] ꞽrm sꜢ [Ptwlmys] ꞽrm sꜢ <supplied reason="lost" evidence="parallel">Ptwlmys</supplied> ı͗rm EpiDoc
Characters now lost, but recorded by earlier scholars (no standard) ꞽ[“mn”].t <supplied reason="lost" evidence="previous_editor">mn</supplied>.t EpiDoc
Partial destruction, but perfectly or unambiguously legible ꞽmn.t
ꞽmn⸢.t⸣
ꞽmn⸢.t⸣ ꞽmn<damage>.t</damage>
ꞽmn<damage degree="medium">.t</damage>
ꞽmn<damage degree="low">.t</damage>
EpiDoc
Partial destruction, interpretation somewhat ambiguous ꞽmn.t?
ꞽmn⸢.t?⸣
δεδαία̣ται
ꞽmn⸢⸮.t?⸣
δεδαία̣ται
ꞽmn<unclear reason="damaged">.t</unclear>
δεδαί<unclear reason="damaged">α</unclear>ται
EpiDoc
==== MODERN EDITORIAL CORRECTIONS, EMENDATIONS, IDEALIZATIONS, ... ====
Questionable interpretation of hieroglyphs wꜥb.t? ⸮wꜥb.t? <unclear>wꜥb.t</unclear> EpiDoc
Erroneous ancient addition ꞽmn{.t}-rꜤ ꞽmn{.t}-rꜤ ꞽmn<surplus reason="mistake">t</surplus>-rꜤ
ꞽmn<surplus reason="mistake" cert="high">t</surplus>-rꜤ
ꞽmn<surplus reason="mistake" cert="low">t</surplus>-rꜤ
EpiDoc
Erroneous ancient repetition ꞽ{ꞽ}mn.t
{ꞽmn} ꞽmn.t
ꞽ{ꞽ}mn.t
{ꞽmn} ꞽmn.t
<surplus reason="repeated"></surplus>mn.t
<surplus reason="repeated" cert="high"></surplus>mn.t
<surplus reason="repeated" cert="low"></surplus>mn.t
TEI
Traditional 'superfluous' double spelling of phonemes (sound change) zw{r}ꞽ
zwrꞽ
t{r}ꞽ
trꞽ
zw{r}ꞽ
t{r}ꞽ
zw<surplus reason="traditional_orthography">r</surplus>
Erroneous ancient omission ꞽmn⟨.w⟩ ꞽmn⟨.w⟩ ꞽmn<supplied reason="omitted">.w</supplied>
ꞽmn<supplied reason="omitted" cert="middle">.w</supplied>
EpiDoc
Erroneous ancient substitution ꞽmn.{t}⟨w⟩
ꞽmn.⟨w⟩
ꞽmn.{t}⟨w⟩ ꞽmn.<choice><sic>t</sic><corr>w</corr></choice> EpiDoc
Regularization of transcription, according to Old Egyptian spelling w{d}⟨ḏ⟩=f
wḏ=f
wd=f
={t}⟨ṯ⟩n
=ṯn
=tn
w{d}⟨ḏ⟩=f
={t}⟨ṯ⟩n
w<choice><orig>d</orig><reg type="Old_Egyptian_form"></reg></choice>=f
=<choice><orig>t</orig><reg type="Old_Egyptian_form ></reg></choice>n
EpiDoc
Regularization of transcription, towards plene spelling sḏm.t(w)=f sḏm.t(w)=f sḏm.t<choice><orig/><reg type="plene_spelling">w</reg></choice>=f EpiDoc
Regularization of transcription, reconstruction according to grammatical theory pr(ꞽ)=f
prꞽ=f
pri̯=f
pr(ꞽ)=f pr<choice><orig/><reg type="theoretical"></reg></choice>f EpiDoc
ꞽw=f (ḥr) sdm ꞽw=f (ḥr) sdm ꞽw=f <choice><orig/><reg type="paradigmatic_normalization">ḥr</reg></choice> sdm
Second/third/... reading of characters only written once (licensed/systemic haplography) (no standard) ꜥnḫ nb wꜣs ⸨nb⸩ snb ⸨nb⸩ <supplied reason="haplography">nb<supplied>
==== FOOTNOTES, COMMENTS, VARIA ====
Modern footnote / endnote [can be automatized; no need to encode by hand] ꞽmn.t tw1
________________
1
Congruent.
ꞽmn.t tw1
________________
1
Congruent.
ꞽmn.t tw<note>Congruent.</note> EpiDoc
Change of hand (not marked) ꞽmn.t (change of hand) pw ꞽmn.t <handShift cert="high" />pw EpiDoc
Text not completed (no standard) ꞽmn.t (unfinished) ꞽmn.t <gap reason="omitted" extent="unknown" /> Ꜣrsn EpiDoc
Abbreviation, without/with expansion ⲓ⳯ⲥ

s(nb)

ⲓ⳯ⲥ

s(nb)

<abbr><am></am></abbr> EpiDoc
EpiDoc
EpiDoc
<expan><abbr><am></am></abbr><ex>ⲥⲟⲩ</ex><abbr></abbr></expan>
<expan>
<abbr>s</abbr> <ex>nb</ex></expan>
Sign or symbol not present in Unicode (no standard) *cross* <g type="cross" />
<g type="circle" />
EpiDoc
==== WORD AND SENTENCE BOUNDARIES (optional) ====
Sentence boundaries ꞽmn.t pw ꞽmn.t pw <s>ꞽmn.t pw</s>
Word boundaries texts without spaces between words ⲁⲛⲟⲕⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥϯ ⲁⲛⲟⲕⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥϯ <w>ⲁⲛⲟⲕ</w><w>ⲡⲁⲡⲁⲥ</w><w>ϯ</w>

TEI tagging of text annotations

Semantic annotation supported by TEI

Personal names and individual persons

Example for individual person in line with EpiDoc 8.21 Guidelines:[1]

  <persName 
    type="royal" 
    ref="http://www.trismegistos.org/person/12909"
    key="Ptolemaios_III_Euergetes_I"> 
    <name
      nymref="http://www.trismegistos.org/name/5317"
      key="Ptolemaios"> 
      Ptrwmys
    </name>
  </persName>

Examples for name (without identification with individual person):

  <persName 
    type="non_royal" 
    key="Amenophis"> 
    <name
      nymref="http://www.trismegistos.org/name/8042" 
      key="Amenophis"> 
      ꞽmn-m-ꞽp.t
    </name>
  </persName>

Place names

Example:

  <placeName type="settlement" key="Elephantine" 
     ref="http://www.trismegistos.org/place/621">Yb</placeName>

Alternatives for "settlement" are "district", "region", "country".

Dates

For dating by regnal years, use @when-custom and @datingMethod, and seperate ruler and regnal year by ":":[2]

  <date when-custom="Ptolemaios_III:11" datingMethod="#regnal_year">ḥsb.t 11</date>

Example for Coptic month:

  <date when-custom="Parmuti:9">ⲡⲁⲣⲙⲁⲧ ⲑ</date>

If you can provide a modern calendar year (TLA chronology, like in the database), add notBefore="..." notAfter="..." plus a precision="..." attribute, e.g.

  <date when-custom="Ptolemaios_III:11" datingMethod="#regnal_year" 
     notBefore="-0236" notAfter="-0235" precision="high">ḥsb.t 11</date>
  <date when-custom="Parmuti:9" notBefore="0450" notAfter="0465" 
     precision="medium">ⲡⲁⲣⲙⲁⲧ ⲑ</date>

Instead of a time span one may refer to an individual year using a when="..." attribute:

  <date when-custom="Ptolemaios_III:11" datingMethod="#regnal_year" 
     when="-0236" precision="high">ḥsb.t 11</date>

Years BC are negative values; year values must have 4 digits. Months may follow and must have 2 digits:

  notBefore="-0236-05" notAfter="-0235-04" 

or

  when="0455-03"

Morphosyntactic annotation

State: in discussion

References

Bibliography

Community.

Stoa Consortium].

  • TEI P5: Guidelines for Electronic Text Encoding and Interchange, Version 2.2.0 (Update: 25. Okt.

2012) / Version 2.3.0 (Update: 17. Jan. 2013) http://www.tei-c.org/Guidelines/P5/, ed. by the TEI Consortium.

  • Werning, Daniel A. 2013 (March). Datenkodierung in TEI XML im Rubensohn-Projekt

http://wwwuser.gwdg.de/~dwernin/drafts/Werning-TEI_im_Rubensohn_Projekt.pdf